Following lists the correspondence between Philip D. Jones and Douglas J. Keenan, during the review of Keenan's article submitted to the journal Energy & Environment (2007).

•  Comments from Jones.
•  Reply from Keenan.
•  Rejoinder from Jones.
•  Advice from Jones to Editor Peiser.
•  Surrejoinder from Keenan, part 1.
•  Surrejoinder from Keenan, part 2.

Note: the other two reviewers recommended accepting the article.